21 thoughts on “Take The Small Account Challenge

  1. Douglas is speaking to a different audience. I am normally as well. The Cash Bomb Sequence is designed to BREAK all the rules of conservative grinding, and replace it with the most extreme risk to reward ratios I have ever discovered. This is what I believe to be required if a trader with just a few thousands is ever to build his or her capital to a meaningful level.

    What good is a competent grinding edge of it only produces $75 a month in income for the small account trader? Whereas that level of performance might be worth $7,500 a month to a trader with a six figure account.

    1. Douglas' comment is intended for ALL traders.

      As to the $75 per month (it should be much more with a good system), the answer is the power of compounding. Better to have a small profit erned consistently over time than a huge loss!

      It seems you are talking about a lottery or casino approach which is not relly what this site is supposed to be about.

      But hey, I suppose that approach would actually work for some.

      But it is a desperation measure as opposed to a systematic knowledge-based approach based on probability and we need to be clear about that.

  2. Patrick, we are competing against the big, the bad, and the properly funded... However, it takes time to build positions of size and that is a big part of our edge as individuals.

    We are the pilot fish following the great whites around.

    P.S. Trading in the zone and Dr. McCall's "The Way Of The Warrior Trader" are my two favorite books on the mental game of trading.

    1. Hi Bo,

      Unless I completely misunderstood Mark Douglas (I did not), this approach is diametrically opposed to what he advocates. Unless I misunderstood your approach (possible) the risks taken are undisciplined and inconsistent with those advocated by Mr. Douglas.

      Patrick

  3. Trading can be considered a poker game - AS LONG AS YOU ARE THE HOUSE!

    Otherwise you are bound to blow your brains out sooner or later.

    I prefer the approach of individuals like Mark Douglas who have studied what make successful traders successful. It is not this wild and wonderful caution to the wind approach. Rather is is disciplined consistency with the odds in your favor.

    My advice is to read Mr. Douglas's book "Trading in the Zone" and follow that.

    It is a classic that needs to be on every trader's desk.

    What is your "edge"?

    If you have none the odds are stacked against you.

    Nevertheless, I suppose there are different strokes for different folks and this may work for some.

    If so, God bless.

    I wish you all "every success" and hope whatever method you chose works for you - just use a method - and stick with it once you find your edge.

    This is not intended as a know it all comment. I am still looking for my edge too - refining a system has proven to be the greatest challenge - one must balance the need for continuous improvement with the competing requirement of stability, discipline and consistency. Meanwhile we are competing against players with more extensive resources and greater inside knowledge (insight) than the little guy can ever hope to have.

    Very long odds it seems.

    Sincerely,

    Patrick Keith

  4. Jack said:

    >Finding potential high reward trades requires more patience and luck >than Muskie fishing.

    This is certainly true. Trading is basically a biz where you sit around waiting for somebody to make a mistake.

    It can be tough to maintain focus as any lapse could cause you to miss the trade that you have spent all day waiting for. This is a systemic issue with daytrading or scalping modules. If this reality leaves you cold and clammy, then I would suggest you take a look at using the ideas in the Cash Bomb Sequence as a swing trade strategy. Picking a timeframe and adapting the Sequence to your needs will be a big topic in the next Training Module.

    Your request Jack got my creative juices flowing. User interactivity and the proof aspect of watching others succeed is a very powerful thing! Let me find out if what I want to build is practical, and if so I will send out an email to my list to invite users to join in... stay tuned!

  5. I tried somewhat similar when I was a total newbie in this business, the outcome was as expected, blowing my small account due to poor money-management. Today, six year later, I do trade now and then with same style with options but now in a controlled way and with success. The whole point with this trading style is waiting right situation to arise, planning losses carefully and sitting tight.

  6. The last commenter is right on the money! The Cash Bomb Sequence is a way for a trader without proper captial to leverage some luck into an account that could really launch them, or for a trader with money to break free from the fears that hold them back.

    Anger or defensiveness are usually rooted in fear...When I am working with a consulting client, and they get huffy or challenged, Like a massage therapist who feels a knotted muscle I know I have hit a nerve. (And press deeper to see if we cannot root out that often limiting fear.)

    Trading is so often perverse... buy when there is fear, sell when there is greed... I find that comfortable and justifiable (scientific) trade plans lose or underpeform, while UNCOMFORTABLE trades deliver the largest edge. (In my view because so few traders understand the trade off between emotional risk and capital risk!)

    I hoped this idea would be a shock to the system that would start people thinking. That is another reason why I designed such a proof element into the live blog. No matter how crazy you think I am for doing this, each and every trade is recorded so there is no debate possible about the realities of each Sequences outcome.

  7. I think the last couple of posts are missing the mark here, if you took 500 and played wild with it and it payed off, would you not take your winnings and move on, leaving the 500 at risk till next time your feeling lucky, and if your feeling lucky and you get burned, well you have limited your loses to what you are able to lose, but I think the real message was, if your not comfortable with the loses that your having maybe your not in the right game, you should be somewhere the risk is less, like a savings account.

  8. If you are not exceptionally well prepared mentally, physically and emotionally guts will translate into stupidity and, no doubt, slaughter you. It's kind of like getting in the ring with Mike Tyson.... Do you know what I mean?

  9. Sorry, but I have to take issue with the 'advice.' Trading should be fun, yes, but it's not some sort of adolescent 'whoopee this is great' kind of thing. Mr. Yoder made money at it? Sure, an experienced and canny trader should make money. Tom had fun with his demo account? Try using real money.
    Many people, myself included, will go to the casino with the same plan. Allocate a small amount (say fifty to a hundred bucks) and have several hours of fun until it runs out. It is fun. But don 't expect to win.
    Bad advice, Mr. Yoder!

  10. Dear Bo:
    That is an interesting article. Are you up for some more fun?

    I have a $1,900.00 cash account with Scottrade. I do not own anything at the moment. I have never traded on the Forex. I don't even know if I can through Scottrade. Anyway, would you like to teach me how to make some money using your technique? Since I really am a true beginner it might be beneficial to both of us if we were successful. I would be pleased and proud to write a day by day report to you that you could use if and/or when you decide to sell your program to others.

    I am retired and have nothing else to do all day long but watch the stock market. Finding potential high reward trades requires more patience and luck than Muskie fishing. I'm getting a llitle bored with the whole thing and may go back to watching paint dry or playing golf.

    I'd love to hear from you.

    Best Regards;
    Jack Nuccio
    Email withheld

  11. I mostly trade forex and since i began trading I have had some extreme experiences. Best result was turning $7,000 into $63,660 overnight, 26 trades all winners. Next night turned the $63,660 into a little over $70,000. Following night lost a little over $35,000. Obviously taking on way too much risk, but it was a great experience. I tend to come out with alot better results when obeying the golden rules, defining entry and exit points prior to entering each trade. I find that when I keep looking at the dollar amount my trade has generated I tend to close the positions to early. I have moved onto longer timeframes (15 min. 1 hour and use the 5 minute for entries. as I found the shorter timeframes (1 minute mostly) way too unpredictable. Scalping seemed hardwork in the end so I rarely practice it these days..

  12. I mostly trade forex and since i began trading I have had some extreme experiences. Best result was turning $7,000 into $63,660 overnight, 26 trades all winners. Next night turned the $63,660 into a little over $70,000. Following night lost a little over $35,000. Obviously taking on way too much risk, but it was a great experience. I tend to come out with alot better results when obeying the golden rules, defining entry and exit points prior to entering each trade. I find that when I keep looking at the dollar amount my trade has generated I tend to close the positions to early. I have moved onto longer timeframes (15 min. 1 hour and use the 5 minute for entries. as I found the shorter timeframes (1 minute mostly) way too unpredictable. Scalping seemed hardwork in the end so I rarely practice it these days.

    1. What a great story!

      It highlights one of the concepts that I am trying to teach with the Cash Bomb Sequence which is to shift your focus from just trade by trade risk to reward levels, and add in the concept of total account value R/R. If you trade 3 Sequences, and make 300% on 2, but lose everything on round three, in my mind that is a 3 to 1 R/R.

      Because...If you trade a small account with aggression, sooner or later you will lose it all. So you really have to embrace that concept of total risk and ONLY put the money you are willing to lose in its entirety into your Cash Bomb Account.

    2. yaitsa goli i say!! well done and thank you for sharing your extreme trading experiences. How have your experiences with brokers been? Who do you use to trade?

  13. I was just doing the same with a demo account, tring to master my chart tech eyesight but treating the money as if real, I was up $5089 in 3 days(+100% gain)...no trade lasted for more than an hour, as I was also prefecting my scalping techniques. I think my trading was enhanced due to the markets being open 24/5 as I could walk away when in a rut and make big profits when I "felt" like it. My total time in 3 days "staring" at a computer-6 hours with 32 trades, with 6 losers for a total of $142.00, and man was it fun!

    1. It sounds like you were in "the zone" there when you said you could feel the market was offering you a trade. This just what the small account challenge can do, help traders get away from worrying about being wrong, or losing money, and just focus on the order flow and the line of least resistance...

      So remember what that experience felt like and try to lock it in. The more time you can spend in the zone, the better your trading will be as that dispassionate objectivity enhances your accuracy and trade selection skills!

Comments are closed.